githubmirror/setools

tests/test_diff.py
2 913 строк119 KB
Chris PeBenito
diff: Replace named tuples with dataclasses.
24 мар 2023, 17:53
24 мар 2023, 17:53450f948
# Copyright 2015-2016, Tresys Technology, LLC
# Copyright 2016, 2017, Chris PeBenito <pebenito@ieee.org>
#
# SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0-only
#
import os
import unittest
from dataclasses import astuple
from ipaddress import IPv6Address, IPv4Network, IPv6Network

from setools import PolicyDifference, PortconProtocol
from setools import BoundsRuletype as BRT
from setools import ConstraintRuletype as CRT
from setools import DefaultRuletype as DRT
from setools import DefaultRangeValue as DRV
from setools import DefaultValue as DV
from setools import FSUseRuletype as FSURT
from setools import MLSRuletype as MRT
from setools import RBACRuletype as RRT
from setools import TERuletype as TRT

from .mixins import ValidateRule
from .policyrep.util import compile_policy


class PolicyDifferenceTest(ValidateRule, unittest.TestCase):

    """Policy difference tests."""

    @classmethod
    def setUpClass(cls):
        cls.p_left = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.p_right = compile_policy("tests/diff_right.conf")
        cls.diff = PolicyDifference(cls.p_left, cls.p_right)

    @classmethod
    def tearDownClass(cls):
        os.unlink(cls.p_left.path)
        os.unlink(cls.p_right.path)

    #
    # Types
    #
    def test_added_types(self):
        """Diff: added type"""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_type"]), self.diff.added_types)

    def test_removed_types(self):
        """Diff: modified type"""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_type"]), self.diff.removed_types)

    def test_modified_types_count(self):
        """Diff: total modified types"""
        self.assertEqual(6, len(self.diff.modified_types))

    def test_modified_types_remove_attr(self):
        """Diff: modified type with removed attribute."""
        self.assertIn("modified_remove_attr", self.diff.modified_types)
        removed_attrs = self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].removed_attributes
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["an_attr"]), removed_attrs)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].added_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].removed_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_attr"].matched_aliases)

    def test_modified_types_remove_alias(self):
        """Diff: modified type with removed alias."""
        self.assertIn("modified_remove_alias", self.diff.modified_types)
        removed_alias = self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].removed_aliases
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["an_alias"]), removed_alias)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].added_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].removed_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_alias"].matched_aliases)

    def test_modified_types_remove_permissive(self):
        """Diff: modified type with removed permissve."""
        self.assertIn("modified_remove_permissive", self.diff.modified_types)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].added_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].removed_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertTrue(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertTrue(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].removed_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_remove_permissive"].matched_aliases)

    def test_modified_types_add_attr(self):
        """Diff: modified type with added attribute."""
        self.assertIn("modified_add_attr", self.diff.modified_types)
        added_attrs = self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].added_attributes
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["an_attr"]), added_attrs)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].removed_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].removed_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_attr"].matched_aliases)

    def test_modified_types_add_alias(self):
        """Diff: modified type with added alias."""
        self.assertIn("modified_add_alias", self.diff.modified_types)
        added_alias = self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].added_aliases
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["an_alias"]), added_alias)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].added_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].removed_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].removed_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_alias"].matched_aliases)

    def test_modified_types_add_permissive(self):
        """Diff: modified type with added permissive."""
        self.assertIn("modified_add_permissive", self.diff.modified_types)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].added_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].removed_attributes)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].matched_attributes)
        self.assertTrue(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].modified_permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].permissive)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].removed_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types["modified_add_permissive"].matched_aliases)

    #
    # Roles
    #
    def test_added_role(self):
        """Diff: added role."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_role"]), self.diff.added_roles)

    def test_removed_role(self):
        """Diff: removed role."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_role"]), self.diff.removed_roles)

    def test_modified_role_count(self):
        """Diff: modified role."""
        self.assertEqual(2, len(self.diff.modified_roles))

    def test_modified_role_add_type(self):
        """Diff: modified role with added type."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["system"]),
                            self.diff.modified_roles["modified_add_type"].added_types)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_roles["modified_add_type"].removed_types)

    def test_modified_role_remove_type(self):
        """Diff: modified role with removed type."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["system"]),
                            self.diff.modified_roles["modified_remove_type"].removed_types)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_roles["modified_remove_type"].added_types)

    #
    # Commons
    #
    def test_added_common(self):
        """Diff: added common."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_common"]), self.diff.added_commons)

    def test_removed_common(self):
        """Diff: removed common."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_common"]), self.diff.removed_commons)

    def test_modified_common_count(self):
        """Diff: modified common count."""
        self.assertEqual(2, len(self.diff.modified_commons))

    def test_modified_common_add_perm(self):
        """Diff: modified common with added perm."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_perm"]),
                            self.diff.modified_commons["modified_add_perm"].added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_commons["modified_add_perm"].removed_perms)

    def test_modified_common_remove_perm(self):
        """Diff: modified common with removed perm."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_perm"]),
                            self.diff.modified_commons["modified_remove_perm"].removed_perms)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_commons["modified_remove_perm"].added_perms)

    #
    # Classes
    #
    def test_added_class(self):
        """Diff: added class."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_class"]), self.diff.added_classes)

    def test_removed_class(self):
        """Diff: removed class."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_class"]), self.diff.removed_classes)

    def test_modified_class_count(self):
        """Diff: modified class count."""
        self.assertEqual(3, len(self.diff.modified_classes))

    def test_modified_class_add_perm(self):
        """Diff: modified class with added perm."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_perm"]),
                            self.diff.modified_classes["modified_add_perm"].added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_classes["modified_add_perm"].removed_perms)

    def test_modified_class_remove_perm(self):
        """Diff: modified class with removed perm."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_perm"]),
                            self.diff.modified_classes["modified_remove_perm"].removed_perms)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_classes["modified_remove_perm"].added_perms)

    def test_modified_class_change_common(self):
        """Diff: modified class due to modified common."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["old_com"]),
                            self.diff.modified_classes["modified_change_common"].removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["new_com"]),
                            self.diff.modified_classes["modified_change_common"].added_perms)

    #
    # Allow rules
    #
    def test_added_allow_rules(self):
        """Diff: added allow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_allows)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.allow, "added_rule_source", "added_rule_target",
                           "infoflow", set(["med_w"]))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.allow, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow2",
                           set(["med_w"]))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.allow, "move_from_bool", "move_from_bool", "infoflow4",
                           set(["hi_r"]))

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.allow, "move_to_bool", "move_to_bool", "infoflow4",
                           set(["hi_w"]), cond="move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.allow, "system", "switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

    def test_removed_allow_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed allow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_allows)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.allow, "move_from_bool", "move_from_bool", "infoflow4",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.allow, "move_to_bool", "move_to_bool", "infoflow4",
                           set(["hi_w"]))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.allow, "removed_rule_source", "removed_rule_target",
                           "infoflow", set(["hi_r"]))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.allow, "removed_type", "removed_type", "infoflow3",
                           set(["null"]))

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.allow, "system", "switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_modified_allow_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified allow rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_allows, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_r"]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_w"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_r"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Auditallow rules
    #
    def test_added_auditallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: added auditallow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_auditallows)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.auditallow, "aa_added_rule_source", "aa_added_rule_target",
                           "infoflow", set(["med_w"]))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.auditallow, "aa_move_from_bool", "aa_move_from_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_r"]))

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.auditallow, "aa_move_to_bool", "aa_move_to_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_w"]), cond="aa_move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.auditallow, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
                           set(["super_none"]))

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.auditallow, "system", "aa_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="aa_switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

    def test_removed_auditallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed auditallow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_auditallows)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.auditallow, "aa_move_from_bool", "aa_move_from_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_r"]), cond="aa_move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.auditallow, "aa_move_to_bool", "aa_move_to_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_w"]))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.auditallow, "aa_removed_rule_source",
                           "aa_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set(["hi_r"]))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.auditallow, "removed_type", "removed_type", "infoflow7",
                           set(["super_unmapped"]))

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.auditallow, "system", "aa_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="aa_switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_modified_auditallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified auditallow rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_auditallows, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_r"]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_w"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallow, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aa_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_r"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Dontaudit rules
    #
    def test_added_dontaudit_rules(self):
        """Diff: added dontaudit rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_dontaudits)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.dontaudit, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
                           set(["super_none"]))

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.dontaudit, "da_added_rule_source", "da_added_rule_target",
                           "infoflow", set(["med_w"]))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.dontaudit, "da_move_from_bool", "da_move_from_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_r"]))

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.dontaudit, "da_move_to_bool", "da_move_to_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_w"]), cond="da_move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.dontaudit, "system", "da_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="da_switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

    def test_removed_dontaudit_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed dontaudit rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_dontaudits)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.dontaudit, "da_move_from_bool", "da_move_from_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_r"]), cond="da_move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.dontaudit, "da_move_to_bool", "da_move_to_bool",
                           "infoflow4", set(["hi_w"]))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.dontaudit, "da_removed_rule_source",
                           "da_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set(["hi_r"]))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.dontaudit, "removed_type", "removed_type", "infoflow7",
                           set(["super_both"]))

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.dontaudit, "system", "da_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           set(["hi_r"]), cond="da_switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_modified_dontaudit_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified dontaudit rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_dontaudits, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontaudit, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontaudit, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_r"]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_w"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontaudit, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("da_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_r"]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Neverallow rules
    #
    def test_added_neverallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: added neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallows)
        # changed after dropping source policy support

        # rules = sorted(self.diff.added_neverallows)
        # self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        # self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.neverallow, "added_type", "added_type", "added_class",
        #                   set(["new_class_perm"]))

        # added rule with existing types
        # self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.neverallow, "na_added_rule_source",
        #                   "na_added_rule_target", "infoflow", set(["med_w"]))

    def test_removed_neverallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallows)
        # changed after dropping source policy support
        # rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_neverallows)
        # self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with existing types
        # self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.neverallow, "na_removed_rule_source",
        #                   "na_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set(["hi_r"]))

        # removed rule with new type
        # self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.neverallow, "removed_type", "removed_type",
        #                   "removed_class", set(["null_perm"]))

    def test_modified_neverallow_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified neverallow rules."""
        # changed after dropping source policy support
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallows)
        # l = sorted(self.diff.modified_neverallows, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        # self.assertEqual(3, len(l))
        #
        # # add permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[0]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallow, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), added_perms)
        # self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), matched_perms)
        #
        # # add and remove permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[1]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallow, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_r"]), added_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["super_w"]), removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)
        #
        # # remove permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[2]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallow, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("na_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_r"]), removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set(["low_w"]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Type_transition rules
    #
    def test_added_type_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: added type_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_type_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_transition, "added_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_transition, "system", "tt_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tt_switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_transition, "tt_added_rule_source",
                           "tt_added_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_transition, "tt_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system")

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_transition, "tt_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system", cond="tt_move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_removed_type_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed type_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_type_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_transition, "removed_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_transition, "system", "tt_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tt_switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_transition, "tt_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system", cond="tt_move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_transition, "tt_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system")

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_transition, "tt_removed_rule_source",
                           "tt_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

    def test_modified_type_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified type_transition rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_type_transitions, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_default, removed_default = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.type_transition, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("tt_matched_source", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertEqual("tt_new_type", added_default)
        self.assertEqual("tt_old_type", removed_default)

    #
    # Type_change rules
    #
    def test_added_type_change_rules(self):
        """Diff: added type_change rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_type_changes)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_change, "added_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_change, "system", "tc_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tc_switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_change, "tc_added_rule_source",
                           "tc_added_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_change, "tc_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system")

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_change, "tc_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system", cond="tc_move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_removed_type_change_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed type_change rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_type_changes)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_change, "removed_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_change, "system", "tc_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tc_switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_change, "tc_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system", cond="tc_move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_change, "tc_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system")

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_change, "tc_removed_rule_source",
                           "tc_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

    def test_modified_type_change_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified type_change rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_type_changes, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_default, removed_default = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.type_change, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("tc_matched_source", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertEqual("tc_new_type", added_default)
        self.assertEqual("tc_old_type", removed_default)

    #
    # Type_member rules
    #
    def test_added_type_member_rules(self):
        """Diff: added type_member rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_type_members)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_member, "added_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_member, "system", "tm_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tm_switch_block_b", cond_block=False)

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_member, "tm_added_rule_source",
                           "tm_added_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_member, "tm_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system")

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_member, "tm_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system", cond="tm_move_to_bool_b", cond_block=True)

    def test_removed_type_member_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed type_member rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_type_members)
        self.assertEqual(5, len(rules))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.type_member, "removed_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # rule moved from one conditional block to another (true to false)
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.type_member, "system", "tm_switch_block", "infoflow6",
                           "system", cond="tm_switch_block_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved out of a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[2], TRT.type_member, "tm_move_from_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow4", "system", cond="tm_move_from_bool_b", cond_block=True)

        # rule moved into a conditional
        self.validate_rule(rules[3], TRT.type_member, "tm_move_to_bool", "system",
                           "infoflow3", "system")

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[4], TRT.type_member, "tm_removed_rule_source",
                           "tm_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", "system")

    def test_modified_type_member_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified type_member rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_type_members, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_default, removed_default = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.type_member, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("tm_matched_source", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertEqual("tm_new_type", added_default)
        self.assertEqual("tm_old_type", removed_default)

    #
    # Range_transition rules
    #
    def test_added_range_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: added range_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_range_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], MRT.range_transition, "added_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "s3")

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], MRT.range_transition, "rt_added_rule_source",
                           "rt_added_rule_target", "infoflow", "s3")

    def test_removed_range_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed range_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_range_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], MRT.range_transition, "removed_type", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "s1")

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], MRT.range_transition, "rt_removed_rule_source",
                           "rt_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", "s1")

    def test_modified_range_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified range_transition rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_range_transitions, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_default, removed_default = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(MRT.range_transition, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("rt_matched_source", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertEqual("s0:c0,c4 - s1:c0.c2,c4", added_default)
        self.assertEqual("s2:c0 - s3:c0.c2", removed_default)

    #
    # Role allow rules
    #
    def test_added_role_allow_rules(self):
        """Diff: added role_allow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_role_allows)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with existing roles
        self.assertEqual(RRT.allow, rules[0].ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("added_role", rules[0].source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rules[0].target)

        # added rule with new roles
        self.assertEqual(RRT.allow, rules[1].ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("added_rule_source_r", rules[1].source)
        self.assertEqual("added_rule_target_r", rules[1].target)

    def test_removed_role_allow_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed role_allow rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_role_allows)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with removed role
        self.assertEqual(RRT.allow, rules[0].ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("removed_role", rules[0].source)
        self.assertEqual("system", rules[0].target)

        # removed rule with existing roles
        self.assertEqual(RRT.allow, rules[1].ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("removed_rule_source_r", rules[1].source)
        self.assertEqual("removed_rule_target_r", rules[1].target)

    #
    # Role_transition rules
    #
    def test_added_role_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: added role_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_role_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with new role
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], RRT.role_transition, "added_role", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # added rule with existing roles
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], RRT.role_transition, "role_tr_added_rule_source",
                           "role_tr_added_rule_target", "infoflow6", "system")

    def test_removed_role_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed role_transition rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_role_transitions)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with new role
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], RRT.role_transition, "removed_role", "system", "infoflow4",
                           "system")

        # removed rule with existing roles
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], RRT.role_transition, "role_tr_removed_rule_source",
                           "role_tr_removed_rule_target", "infoflow5", "system")

    def test_modified_role_transition_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified role_transition rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_role_transitions, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_default, removed_default = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(RRT.role_transition, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("role_tr_matched_source", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("role_tr_matched_target", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", rule.tclass)
        self.assertEqual("role_tr_new_role", added_default)
        self.assertEqual("role_tr_old_role", removed_default)

    #
    # Users
    #
    def test_added_user(self):
        """Diff: added user."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_user"]), self.diff.added_users)

    def test_removed_user(self):
        """Diff: removed user."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_user"]), self.diff.removed_users)

    def test_modified_user_count(self):
        """Diff: modified user count."""
        self.assertEqual(4, len(self.diff.modified_users))

    def test_modified_user_add_role(self):
        """Diff: modified user with added role."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_role"]),
                            self.diff.modified_users["modified_add_role"].added_roles)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_users["modified_add_role"].removed_roles)

    def test_modified_user_remove_role(self):
        """Diff: modified user with removed role."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_role"]),
                            self.diff.modified_users["modified_remove_role"].removed_roles)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_users["modified_remove_role"].added_roles)

    def test_modified_user_change_level(self):
        """Diff: modified user due to modified default level."""
        self.assertEqual("s2:c0", self.diff.modified_users["modified_change_level"].removed_level)
        self.assertEqual("s2:c1", self.diff.modified_users["modified_change_level"].added_level)

    def test_modified_user_change_range(self):
        """Diff: modified user due to modified range."""
        self.assertEqual("s3:c1 - s3:c1.c3",
                         self.diff.modified_users["modified_change_range"].removed_range)
        self.assertEqual("s3:c1 - s3:c1.c4",
                         self.diff.modified_users["modified_change_range"].added_range)

    #
    # Type attributes
    #
    def test_added_type_attribute(self):
        """Diff: added type attribute."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_attr"]), self.diff.added_type_attributes)

    def test_removed_type_attribute(self):
        """Diff: removed type attribute."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_attr"]), self.diff.removed_type_attributes)

    def test_modified_type_attribute(self):
        """Diff: modified type attribute."""
        self.assertEqual(1, len(self.diff.modified_type_attributes))
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["modified_add_attr"]),
                            self.diff.modified_type_attributes["an_attr"].added_types)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["modified_remove_attr"]),
                            self.diff.modified_type_attributes["an_attr"].removed_types)

    #
    # Booleans
    #
    def test_added_boolean(self):
        """Diff: added boolean."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["added_bool"]), self.diff.added_booleans)

    def test_removed_boolean(self):
        """Diff: removed boolean."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_bool"]), self.diff.removed_booleans)

    def test_modified_boolean(self):
        """Diff: modified boolean."""
        self.assertEqual(1, len(self.diff.modified_booleans))
        self.assertTrue(self.diff.modified_booleans["modified_bool"].added_state)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_booleans["modified_bool"].removed_state)

    #
    # Categories
    #
    def test_added_category(self):
        """Diff: added category."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["c6"]), self.diff.added_categories)

    def test_removed_category(self):
        """Diff: removed category."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["c5"]), self.diff.removed_categories)

    def test_modified_category(self):
        """Diff: modified categories."""
        self.assertEqual(2, len(self.diff.modified_categories))

        # add alias
        self.assertEqual(set(["foo"]), self.diff.modified_categories["c1"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_categories["c1"].removed_aliases)

        # remove alias
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_categories["c0"].added_aliases)
        self.assertEqual(set(["eggs"]), self.diff.modified_categories["c0"].removed_aliases)

    #
    # Sensitivity
    #
    def test_added_sensitivities(self):
        """Diff: added sensitivities."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["s46"]), self.diff.added_sensitivities)

    def test_removed_sensitivities(self):
        """Diff: removed sensitivities."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["s47"]), self.diff.removed_sensitivities)

    def test_modified_sensitivities(self):
        """Diff: modified sensitivities."""
        self.assertEqual(2, len(self.diff.modified_sensitivities))

        # add alias
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["al4"]), self.diff.modified_sensitivities["s1"].added_aliases)
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_sensitivities["s1"].removed_aliases)

        # remove alias
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_sensitivities["s0"].added_aliases)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["al2"]), self.diff.modified_sensitivities["s0"].removed_aliases)

    #
    # Initial SIDs
    #
    def test_added_initialsids(self):
        """Diff: added initialsids."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["file_labels"]), self.diff.added_initialsids)

    @unittest.skip("Moved to PolicyDifferenceRmIsidTest.")
    def test_removed_initialsids(self):
        """Diff: removed initialsids."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["removed_sid"]), self.diff.removed_initialsids)

    def test_modified_initialsids(self):
        """Diff: modified initialsids."""
        self.assertEqual(1, len(self.diff.modified_initialsids))
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0",
                         self.diff.modified_initialsids["fs"].added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:system:system:s0",
                         self.diff.modified_initialsids["fs"].removed_context)

    #
    # fs_use_*
    #
    def test_added_fs_uses(self):
        """Diff: added fs_uses."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_fs_uses)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(FSURT.fs_use_xattr, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("added_fsuse", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_removed_fs_uses(self):
        """Diff: removed fs_uses."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_fs_uses)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(FSURT.fs_use_task, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("removed_fsuse", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_modified_fs_uses(self):
        """Diff: modified fs_uses."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_fs_uses, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(FSURT.fs_use_trans, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("modified_fsuse", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s1", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)

    #
    # genfscon
    #
    def test_added_genfscons(self):
        """Diff: added genfscons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_genfscons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual("added_genfs", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("/", rule.path)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

        rule = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual("change_path", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("/new", rule.path)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_removed_genfscons(self):
        """Diff: removed genfscons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_genfscons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual("change_path", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("/old", rule.path)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

        rule = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual("removed_genfs", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("/", rule.path)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_modified_genfscons(self):
        """Diff: modified genfscons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_genfscons, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual("modified_genfs", rule.fs)
        self.assertEqual("/", rule.path)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)

    #
    # level decl
    #
    def test_added_levels(self):
        """Diff: added levels."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_levels)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))
        self.assertEqual("s46:c0.c4", lst[0])

    def test_removed_levels(self):
        """Diff: removed levels."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_levels)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))
        self.assertEqual("s47:c0.c4", lst[0])

    def test_modified_levels(self):
        """Diff: modified levels."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_levels)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        level = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual("s40", level.level.sensitivity)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["c3"]), level.added_categories)
        self.assertFalse(level.removed_categories)

        level = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual("s41", level.level.sensitivity)
        self.assertFalse(level.added_categories)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["c4"]), level.removed_categories)

    #
    # netifcon
    #
    def test_added_netifcons(self):
        """Diff: added netifcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_netifcons)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual("added_netif", rule.netif)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.packet)

    def test_removed_netifcons(self):
        """Diff: removed netifcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_netifcons)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        rule = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual("removed_netif", rule.netif)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.context)
        self.assertEqual("system:object_r:system:s0", rule.packet)

    def test_modified_netifcons(self):
        """Diff: modified netifcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_netifcons, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # modified both contexts
        rule, added_context, removed_context, added_packet, removed_packet = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual("mod_both_netif", rule.netif)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", added_packet)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_packet)

        # modified context
        rule, added_context, removed_context, added_packet, removed_packet = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual("mod_ctx_netif", rule.netif)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)
        self.assertIsNone(added_packet)
        self.assertIsNone(removed_packet)

        # modified packet context
        rule, added_context, removed_context, added_packet, removed_packet = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual("mod_pkt_netif", rule.netif)
        self.assertIsNone(added_context)
        self.assertIsNone(removed_context)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s0", added_packet)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_packet)

    #
    # nodecons
    #
    def test_added_nodecons(self):
        """Diff: added nodecons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_nodecons)
        self.assertEqual(4, len(lst))

        # new IPv4
        nodecon = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(IPv4Network("124.0.0.0/8"), nodecon.network)

        # changed IPv4 netmask
        nodecon = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(IPv4Network("125.0.0.0/16"), nodecon.network)

        # new IPv6
        nodecon = lst[2]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Network("ff04::/62"), nodecon.network)

        # changed IPv6 netmask
        nodecon = lst[3]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Network("ff05::/60"), nodecon.network)

    def test_removed_nodecons(self):
        """Diff: removed nodecons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_nodecons)
        self.assertEqual(4, len(lst))

        # new IPv4
        nodecon = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(IPv4Network("122.0.0.0/8"), nodecon.network)

        # changed IPv4 netmask
        nodecon = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(IPv4Network("125.0.0.0/8"), nodecon.network)

        # new IPv6
        nodecon = lst[2]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Network("ff02::/62"), nodecon.network)

        # changed IPv6 netmask
        nodecon = lst[3]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Network("ff05::/62"), nodecon.network)

    def test_modified_nodecons(self):
        """Diff: modified nodecons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_nodecons, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        # changed IPv4
        nodecon, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(IPv4Network("123.0.0.0/8"), nodecon.network)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c0", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c1", removed_context)

        # changed IPv6
        nodecon, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Network("ff03::/62"), nodecon.network)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c1", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c0.c1", removed_context)

    #
    # Policy capabilities
    #
    def test_added_polcaps(self):
        """Diff: added polcaps."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["always_check_network"]), self.diff.added_polcaps)

    def test_removed_polcaps(self):
        """Diff: removed polcaps."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["network_peer_controls"]), self.diff.removed_polcaps)

    #
    # portcons
    #
    def test_added_portcons(self):
        """Diff: added portcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_portcons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        portcon = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.tcp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((2024, 2026), portcon.ports)

        portcon = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.udp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((2024, 2024), portcon.ports)

    def test_removed_portcons(self):
        """Diff: removed portcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_portcons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        portcon = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.tcp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((1024, 1026), portcon.ports)

        portcon = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.udp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((1024, 1024), portcon.ports)

    def test_modified_portcons(self):
        """Diff: modified portcons."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_portcons, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        portcon, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.tcp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((3024, 3026), portcon.ports)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s1", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)

        portcon, added_context, removed_context = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(PortconProtocol.udp, portcon.protocol)
        self.assertTupleEqual((3024, 3024), portcon.ports)
        self.assertEqual("added_user:object_r:system:s1", added_context)
        self.assertEqual("removed_user:object_r:system:s0", removed_context)

    #
    # defaults
    #
    def test_added_defaults(self):
        """Diff: added defaults."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_defaults)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        default = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_range, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", default.tclass)

        default = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_user, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", default.tclass)

    def test_removed_defaults(self):
        """Diff: removed defaults."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_defaults)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        default = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_range, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", default.tclass)

        default = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_role, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", default.tclass)

    def test_modified_defaults(self):
        """Diff: modified defaults."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_defaults, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(4, len(lst))

        default, added_default, removed_default, added_range, removed_range = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_range, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", default.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(DV.target, added_default)
        self.assertEqual(DV.source, removed_default)
        self.assertIsNone(added_range)
        self.assertIsNone(removed_range)

        default, added_default, removed_default, added_range, removed_range = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_range, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", default.tclass)
        self.assertIsNone(added_default)
        self.assertIsNone(removed_default)
        self.assertEqual(DRV.high, added_range)
        self.assertEqual(DRV.low, removed_range)

        default, added_default, removed_default, added_range, removed_range = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_range, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow6", default.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(DV.target, added_default)
        self.assertEqual(DV.source, removed_default)
        self.assertEqual(DRV.low, added_range)
        self.assertEqual(DRV.high, removed_range)

        default, added_default, removed_default, added_range, removed_range = astuple(lst[3])
        self.assertEqual(DRT.default_type, default.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", default.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(DV.target, added_default)
        self.assertEqual(DV.source, removed_default)
        self.assertIsNone(added_range)
        self.assertIsNone(removed_range)

    #
    # constrains
    #
    def test_added_constrains(self):
        """Diff: added constrains."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_constrains)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        constrain = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.constrain, constrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", constrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["null"]), constrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(["u1", "u2", "!="], constrain.expression)

        constrain = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.constrain, constrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", constrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), constrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't1', set(["system"]), '!=', 'or'],
            constrain.expression)

    def test_removed_constrains(self):
        """Diff: removed constrains."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_constrains)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        constrain = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.constrain, constrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", constrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), constrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(["u1", "u2", "!="], constrain.expression)

        constrain = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.constrain, constrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", constrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), constrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't1', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
            constrain.expression)

    #
    # mlsconstrains
    #
    def test_added_mlsconstrains(self):
        """Diff: added mlsconstrains."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        mlsconstrain = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsconstrain, mlsconstrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", mlsconstrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["null"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby', 'and',
                't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '!=', 'or'],
            mlsconstrain.expression)

        mlsconstrain = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsconstrain, mlsconstrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsconstrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'incomp',
                'and', 't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsconstrain.expression)

    def test_removed_mlsconstrains(self):
        """Diff: removed mlsconstrains."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        mlsconstrain = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsconstrain, mlsconstrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", mlsconstrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby', 'and',
                't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsconstrain.expression)

        mlsconstrain = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsconstrain, mlsconstrain.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsconstrain.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'dom', 'and', 't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsconstrain.expression)

    #
    # validatetrans
    #
    def test_added_validatetrans(self):
        """Diff: added validatetrans."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_validatetrans)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        validatetrans = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.validatetrans, validatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", validatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['t1', 't2', '==', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
            validatetrans.expression)

        validatetrans = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.validatetrans, validatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", validatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['u1', 'u2', '!=', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
            validatetrans.expression)

    def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
        """Diff: removed validatetrans."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        validatetrans = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.validatetrans, validatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", validatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['u1', 'u2', '==', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
            validatetrans.expression)

        validatetrans = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.validatetrans, validatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", validatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '!=', 'and', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
            validatetrans.expression)

    #
    # mlsvalidatetrans
    #
    def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """Diff: added mlsvalidatetrans."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        mlsvalidatetrans = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsvalidatetrans, mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow3", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', '==', 'h1', 'h2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsvalidatetrans.expression)

        mlsvalidatetrans = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsvalidatetrans, mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'incomp', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby',
                'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsvalidatetrans.expression)

    def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """Diff: removed mlsvalidatetrans."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(lst))

        mlsvalidatetrans = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsvalidatetrans, mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow4", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', '==', 'h1', 'h2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsvalidatetrans.expression)

        mlsvalidatetrans = lst[1]
        self.assertEqual(CRT.mlsvalidatetrans, mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
        self.assertEqual(
            ['l1', 'l2', 'dom', 'h1', 'h2', 'dom', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
            mlsvalidatetrans.expression)

    #
    # typebounds
    #
    def test_added_typebounds(self):
        """Diff: added typebounds."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.added_typebounds)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        bounds = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(BRT.typebounds, bounds.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("added_parent", bounds.parent)
        self.assertEqual("added_child", bounds.child)

    def test_removed_typebounds(self):
        """Diff: removed typebounds."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.removed_typebounds)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        bounds = lst[0]
        self.assertEqual(BRT.typebounds, bounds.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("removed_parent", bounds.parent)
        self.assertEqual("removed_child", bounds.child)

    def test_modified_typebounds(self):
        """Diff: modified typebounds."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_typebounds, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(lst))

        bounds, added_bound, removed_bound = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(BRT.typebounds, bounds.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("mod_child", bounds.child)
        self.assertEqual("mod_parent_added", added_bound)
        self.assertEqual("mod_parent_removed", removed_bound)

    #
    # Allowxperm rules
    #
    def test_added_allowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: added allowxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_allowxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.allowxperm, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
                           set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.allowxperm, "ax_added_rule_source", "ax_added_rule_target",
                           "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_removed_allowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed allowxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_allowxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.allowxperm, "ax_removed_rule_source",
                           "ax_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.allowxperm, "removed_type", "removed_type", "infoflow7",
                           set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_modified_allowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified allowxperm rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_allowxperms, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x000f]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0004]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0007]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0008]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.allowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("ax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0005]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Auditallowxperm rules
    #
    def test_added_auditallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: added auditallowxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_auditallowxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.auditallowxperm, "aax_added_rule_source",
                           "aax_added_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.auditallowxperm, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
                           set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_removed_auditallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed auditallowxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_auditallowxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.auditallowxperm, "aax_removed_rule_source",
                           "aax_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.auditallowxperm, "removed_type", "removed_type",
                           "infoflow7", set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_modified_auditallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified auditallowxperm rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_auditallowxperms, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x000f]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0004]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0007]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0008]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.auditallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("aax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0005]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Neverallowxperm rules
    #
    def test_added_neverallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: added neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallowxperms)
        # changed after dropping source policy support
        # rules = sorted(self.diff.added_neverallowxperms)
        # self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))
        #
        # # added rule with new type
        # self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.neverallowxperm, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
        #                    set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")
        #
        # # added rule with existing types
        # self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.neverallowxperm, "nax_added_rule_source",
        #                    "nax_added_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_removed_neverallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallowxperms)
        # changed after dropping source policy support
        # rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_neverallowxperms)
        # self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))
        #
        # # removed rule with existing types
        # self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.neverallowxperm, "nax_removed_rule_source",
        #                    "nax_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")
        #
        # # removed rule with new type
        # self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.neverallowxperm, "removed_type", "removed_type",
        #                    "infoflow7", set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_modified_neverallowxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallowxperms)
        # changed after dropping source policy support
        # l = sorted(self.diff.modified_neverallowxperms, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        # self.assertEqual(3, len(l))
        #
        # # add permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[0]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x000f]), added_perms)
        # self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0004]), matched_perms)
        #
        # # add and remove permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[1]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), added_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0007]), removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0008]), matched_perms)
        #
        # # remove permissions
        # rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = l[2]
        # self.assertEqual(TRT.neverallowxperm, rule.ruletype)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        # self.assertEqual("nax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        # self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        # self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), removed_perms)
        # self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0005]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Dontauditxperm rules
    #
    def test_added_dontauditxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: added dontauditxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_dontauditxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # added rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.dontauditxperm, "added_type", "added_type", "infoflow7",
                           set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

        # added rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.dontauditxperm, "dax_added_rule_source",
                           "dax_added_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_removed_dontauditxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: removed dontauditxperm rules."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_dontauditxperms)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        # removed rule with existing types
        self.validate_rule(rules[0], TRT.dontauditxperm, "dax_removed_rule_source",
                           "dax_removed_rule_target", "infoflow", set([0x0002]), xperm="ioctl")

        # removed rule with new type
        self.validate_rule(rules[1], TRT.dontauditxperm, "removed_type", "removed_type",
                           "infoflow7", set([0x0009]), xperm="ioctl")

    def test_modified_dontauditxperm_rules(self):
        """Diff: modified dontauditxperm rules."""
        lst = sorted(self.diff.modified_dontauditxperms, key=lambda x: x.rule)
        self.assertEqual(3, len(lst))

        # add permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[0])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontauditxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_add_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x000f]), added_perms)
        self.assertFalse(removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0004]), matched_perms)

        # add and remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[1])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontauditxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_add_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow2", rule.tclass)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0007]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0008]), matched_perms)

        # remove permissions
        rule, added_perms, removed_perms, matched_perms = astuple(lst[2])
        self.assertEqual(TRT.dontauditxperm, rule.ruletype)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.source)
        self.assertEqual("dax_modified_rule_remove_perms", rule.target)
        self.assertEqual("infoflow", rule.tclass)
        self.assertFalse(added_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0006]), removed_perms)
        self.assertSetEqual(set([0x0005]), matched_perms)

    #
    # Ibendportcon statements
    #
    def test_added_ibendportcons(self):
        """Diff: added ibendportcon statements."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_ibendportcons)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(rules))
        self.assertEqual("add", rules[0].name)
        self.assertEqual(23, rules[0].port)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rules[0].context)

    def test_removed_ibendportcons(self):
        """Diff: removed ibendportcon statements."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_ibendportcons)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(rules))
        self.assertEqual("removed", rules[0].name)
        self.assertEqual(7, rules[0].port)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rules[0].context)

    def test_modified_ibendportcons(self):
        """Diff: modified ibendportcon statements"""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.modified_ibendportcons)
        self.assertEqual(1, len(rules))

        rule, added, removed = astuple(rules[0])
        self.assertEqual("modified", rule.name)
        self.assertEqual(13, rule.port)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2", added)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c0.c1", removed)

    #
    # Ibpkeycon statements
    #
    def test_added_ibpkeycons(self):
        """Diff: added ibpkeycon statements."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.added_ibpkeycons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        rule = rules[0]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("beef::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xe, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xe, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rule.context)

        rule = rules[1]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("dead::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xbeef, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xdead, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_removed_ibpkeycons(self):
        """Diff: removed ibpkeycon statements."""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.removed_ibpkeycons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        rule = rules[0]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("dccc::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xc, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xc, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rule.context)

        rule = rules[1]
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("feee::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xaaaa, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xbbbb, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("system:system:system:s0", rule.context)

    def test_modified_ibpkeycons(self):
        """Diff: modified ibpkeycon statements"""
        rules = sorted(self.diff.modified_ibpkeycons)
        self.assertEqual(2, len(rules))

        rule, added, removed = astuple(rules[0])
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("aaaa::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xcccc, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xdddd, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c0", added)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c1", removed)

        rule, added, removed = astuple(rules[1])
        self.assertEqual(IPv6Address("bbbb::"), rule.subnet_prefix)
        self.assertEqual(0xf, rule.pkeys.low)
        self.assertEqual(0xf, rule.pkeys.high)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c1", added)
        self.assertEqual("modified_change_level:object_r:system:s2:c0.c1", removed)


class PolicyDifferenceRmIsidTest(unittest.TestCase):

    """
    Policy difference test for removed initial SID.

    Since initial SID names are fixed (they don't exist in the binary policy)
    this cannot be in the above test suite.
    """

    @classmethod
    def setUpClass(cls):
        cls.p_left = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.p_right = compile_policy("tests/diff_right_rmisid.conf")
        cls.diff = PolicyDifference(cls.p_left, cls.p_right)

    @classmethod
    def tearDownClass(cls):
        os.unlink(cls.p_left.path)
        os.unlink(cls.p_right.path)

    def test_removed_initialsids(self):
        """Diff: removed initialsids."""
        self.assertSetEqual(set(["file"]), self.diff.removed_initialsids)


class PolicyDifferenceTestNoDiff(unittest.TestCase):

    """Policy difference test with no policy differences."""

    @classmethod
    def setUpClass(cls):
        cls.p_left = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.p_right = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.diff = PolicyDifference(cls.p_left, cls.p_right)

    @classmethod
    def tearDownClass(cls):
        os.unlink(cls.p_left.path)
        os.unlink(cls.p_right.path)

    def test_added_types(self):
        """NoDiff: no added types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_types)

    def test_removed_types(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_types)

    def test_modified_types(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types)

    def test_added_roles(self):
        """NoDiff: no added roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_roles)

    def test_removed_roles(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_roles)

    def test_modified_roles(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_roles)

    def test_added_commons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_commons)

    def test_removed_commons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_commons)

    def test_modified_commons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_commons)

    def test_added_classes(self):
        """NoDiff: no added classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_classes)

    def test_removed_classes(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_classes)

    def test_modified_classes(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_classes)

    def test_added_allows(self):
        """NoDiff: no added allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_allows)

    def test_removed_allows(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_allows)

    def test_modified_allows(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_allows)

    def test_added_auditallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no added auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_auditallows)

    def test_removed_auditallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_auditallows)

    def test_modified_auditallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_auditallows)

    def test_added_neverallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no added neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallows)

    def test_removed_neverallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallows)

    def test_modified_neverallows(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallows)

    def test_added_dontaudits(self):
        """NoDiff: no added dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_dontaudits)

    def test_removed_dontaudits(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_dontaudits)

    def test_modified_dontaudits(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_dontaudits)

    def test_added_type_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no added type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_transitions)

    def test_removed_type_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_transitions)

    def test_modified_type_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_transitions)

    def test_added_type_changes(self):
        """NoDiff: no added type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_changes)

    def test_removed_type_changes(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_changes)

    def test_modified_type_changes(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_changes)

    def test_added_type_members(self):
        """NoDiff: no added type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_members)

    def test_removed_type_members(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_members)

    def test_modified_type_members(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_members)

    def test_added_range_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no added range_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_range_transitions)

    def test_removed_range_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed range_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_range_transitions)

    def test_modified_range_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified range_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_range_transitions)

    def test_added_role_allows(self):
        """NoDiff: no added role_allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_role_allows)

    def test_removed_role_allows(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed role_allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_role_allows)

    def test_added_role_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no added role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_role_transitions)

    def test_removed_role_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_role_transitions)

    def test_modified_role_transitions(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_role_transitions)

    def test_added_users(self):
        """NoDiff: no added users."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_users)

    def test_removed_users(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed users."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_users)

    def test_modified_users(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified user rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_users)

    def test_added_type_attributes(self):
        """NoDiff: no added type attribute."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_attributes)

    def test_removed_type_attributes(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed type attributes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_attributes)

    def test_modified_type_attributes(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified type attributes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_attributes)

    def test_added_booleans(self):
        """NoDiff: no added booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_booleans)

    def test_removed_booleans(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_booleans)

    def test_modified_booleans(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_booleans)

    def test_added_categories(self):
        """NoDiff: no added categories."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_categories)

    def test_removed_categories(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed categories."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_categories)

    def test_modified_categories(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified categories."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_categories)

    def test_added_sensitivities(self):
        """NoDiff: no added sensitivities."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_sensitivities)

    def test_removed_sensitivities(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed sensitivities."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_sensitivities)

    def test_modified_sensitivities(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified sensitivities."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_sensitivities)

    def test_added_initialsids(self):
        """NoDiff: no added initialsids."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_initialsids)

    def test_removed_initialsids(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed initialsids."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_initialsids)

    def test_modified_initialsids(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified initialsids."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_initialsids)

    def test_added_fs_uses(self):
        """NoDiff: no added fs_uses."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_fs_uses)

    def test_removed_fs_uses(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed fs_uses."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_fs_uses)

    def test_modified_fs_uses(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified fs_uses."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_fs_uses)

    def test_added_genfscons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added genfscons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_genfscons)

    def test_removed_genfscons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed genfscons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_genfscons)

    def test_modified_genfscons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified genfscons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_genfscons)

    def test_added_levels(self):
        """NoDiff: no added levels."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_levels)

    def test_removed_levels(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed levels."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_levels)

    def test_modified_levels(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified levels."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_levels)

    def test_added_netifcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added netifcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_netifcons)

    def test_removed_netifcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed netifcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_netifcons)

    def test_modified_netifcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified netifcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_netifcons)

    def test_added_nodecons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added nodecons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_nodecons)

    def test_removed_nodecons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed nodecons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_nodecons)

    def test_modified_nodecons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified nodecons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_nodecons)

    def test_added_polcaps(self):
        """NoDiff: no added polcaps."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_polcaps)

    def test_removed_polcaps(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed polcaps."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_polcaps)

    def test_added_portcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added portcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_portcons)

    def test_removed_portcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed portcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_portcons)

    def test_modified_portcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified portcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_portcons)

    def test_modified_properties(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified properties."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_properties)

    def test_added_defaults(self):
        """NoDiff: no added defaults."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_defaults)

    def test_removed_defaults(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed defaults."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_defaults)

    def test_modified_defaults(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified defaults."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_defaults)

    def test_added_constrains(self):
        """NoDiff: no added constrains."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_constrains)

    def test_removed_constrains(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed constrains."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_constrains)

    def test_added_mlsconstrains(self):
        """NoDiff: no added mlsconstrains."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)

    def test_removed_mlsconstrains(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed mlsconstrains."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains)

    def test_added_validatetrans(self):
        """NoDiff: no added validatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_validatetrans)

    def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed validatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)

    def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """NoDiff: no added mlsvalidatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)

    def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed mlsvalidatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)

    def test_added_typebounds(self):
        """NoDiff: no added typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_typebounds)

    def test_removed_typebounds(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_typebounds)

    def test_modified_typebounds(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_typebounds)

    def test_added_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_allowxperms)

    def test_removed_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_allowxperms)

    def test_modified_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_allowxperms)

    def test_added_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_auditallowxperms)

    def test_removed_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_auditallowxperms)

    def test_modified_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_auditallowxperms)

    def test_added_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallowxperms)

    def test_removed_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallowxperms)

    def test_modified_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallowxperms)

    def test_added_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_dontauditxperms)

    def test_removed_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_dontauditxperms)

    def test_modified_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_dontauditxperms)

    def test_added_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_ibendportcons)

    def test_removed_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_ibendportcons)

    def test_modified_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_ibendportcons)

    def test_added_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_ibpkeycons)

    def test_removed_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_ibpkeycons)

    def test_modified_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_ibpkeycons)


class PolicyDifferenceTestMLStoStandard(unittest.TestCase):

    """
    Policy difference test between MLS and standard (non-MLS) policy.

    The left policy is an MLS policy.  The right policy is identical to the
    left policy, except with MLS disabled.
    """

    @classmethod
    def setUpClass(cls):
        cls.p_left = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.p_right = compile_policy("tests/diff_left_standard.conf", mls=False)
        cls.diff = PolicyDifference(cls.p_left, cls.p_right)

    @classmethod
    def tearDownClass(cls):
        os.unlink(cls.p_left.path)
        os.unlink(cls.p_right.path)

    def test_added_types(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_types)

    def test_removed_types(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_types)

    def test_modified_types(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified types"""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_types)

    def test_added_roles(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_roles)

    def test_removed_roles(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_roles)

    def test_modified_roles(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified roles."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_roles)

    def test_added_commons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_commons)

    def test_removed_commons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_commons)

    def test_modified_commons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified commons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_commons)

    def test_added_classes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_classes)

    def test_removed_classes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_classes)

    def test_modified_classes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified classes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_classes)

    def test_added_allows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_allows)

    def test_removed_allows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_allows)

    def test_modified_allows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_allows)

    def test_added_auditallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_auditallows)

    def test_removed_auditallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_auditallows)

    def test_modified_auditallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified auditallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_auditallows)

    def test_added_neverallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallows)

    def test_removed_neverallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallows)

    def test_modified_neverallows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified neverallow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallows)

    def test_added_dontaudits(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_dontaudits)

    def test_removed_dontaudits(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_dontaudits)

    def test_modified_dontaudits(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified dontaudit rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_dontaudits)

    def test_added_type_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_transitions)

    def test_removed_type_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_transitions)

    def test_modified_type_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified type_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_transitions)

    def test_added_type_changes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_changes)

    def test_removed_type_changes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_changes)

    def test_modified_type_changes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified type_change rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_changes)

    def test_added_type_members(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_members)

    def test_removed_type_members(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_members)

    def test_modified_type_members(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified type_member rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_members)

    def test_added_range_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added range_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_range_transitions)

    def test_removed_range_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all range_transition rules removed."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.range_transition_count,
                         len(self.diff.removed_range_transitions))

    def test_modified_range_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified range_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_range_transitions)

    def test_added_role_allows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added role_allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_role_allows)

    def test_removed_role_allows(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed role_allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_role_allows)

    def test_added_role_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_role_transitions)

    def test_removed_role_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_role_transitions)

    def test_modified_role_transitions(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified role_transition rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_role_transitions)

    def test_added_users(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added users."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_users)

    def test_removed_users(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed users."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_users)

    def test_modified_users(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all users modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.user_count, len(self.diff.modified_users))

    def test_added_type_attributes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added type attribute."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_type_attributes)

    def test_removed_type_attributes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed type attributes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_type_attributes)

    def test_modified_type_attributes(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified type attributes."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_type_attributes)

    def test_added_booleans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_booleans)

    def test_removed_booleans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_booleans)

    def test_modified_booleans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified booleans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_booleans)

    def test_added_categories(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added categories."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_categories)

    def test_removed_categories(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all categories removed."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.category_count, len(self.diff.removed_categories))

    def test_modified_categories(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified categories."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_categories)

    def test_added_sensitivities(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added sensitivities."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_sensitivities)

    def test_removed_sensitivities(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all sensitivities removed."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.level_count, len(self.diff.removed_sensitivities))

    def test_modified_sensitivities(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified sensitivities."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_sensitivities)

    def test_added_initialsids(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added initialsids."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_initialsids)

    def test_removed_initialsids(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed initialsids."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_initialsids)

    def test_modified_initialsids(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all initialsids modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.initialsids_count,
                         len(self.diff.modified_initialsids))

    def test_added_fs_uses(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added fs_uses."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_fs_uses)

    def test_removed_fs_uses(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed fs_uses."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_fs_uses)

    def test_modified_fs_uses(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all fs_uses modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.fs_use_count, len(self.diff.modified_fs_uses))

    def test_added_genfscons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added genfscons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_genfscons)

    def test_removed_genfscons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed genfscons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_genfscons)

    def test_modified_genfscons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all genfscons modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.genfscon_count, len(self.diff.modified_genfscons))

    def test_added_levels(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added levels."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_levels)

    def test_removed_levels(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all levels removed."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.level_count, len(self.diff.removed_levels))

    def test_modified_levels(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified levels."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_levels)

    def test_added_netifcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added netifcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_netifcons)

    def test_removed_netifcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed netifcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_netifcons)

    def test_modified_netifcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all netifcons modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.netifcon_count, len(self.diff.modified_netifcons))

    def test_added_nodecons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added nodecons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_nodecons)

    def test_removed_nodecons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed nodecons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_nodecons)

    def test_modified_nodecons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all nodecons modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.nodecon_count, len(self.diff.modified_nodecons))

    def test_added_polcaps(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added polcaps."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_polcaps)

    def test_removed_polcaps(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed polcaps."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_polcaps)

    def test_added_portcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added portcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_portcons)

    def test_removed_portcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed portcons."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_portcons)

    def test_modified_portcons(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all portcons modified."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.portcon_count, len(self.diff.modified_portcons))

    def test_modified_properties(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: MLS property modified only."""
        self.assertEqual(1, len(self.diff.modified_properties))

        name, added, removed = astuple(self.diff.modified_properties[0])
        self.assertEqual("MLS", name)
        self.assertIs(False, added)
        self.assertIs(True, removed)

    def test_added_defaults(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added defaults."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_defaults)

    def test_removed_defaults(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all default_range removed."""
        self.assertEqual(
            sum(1 for d in self.diff.left_policy.defaults() if d.ruletype == DRT.default_range),
            len(self.diff.removed_defaults))

    def test_modified_defaults(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no defaults modified."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_defaults)

    def test_added_constraints(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added constraints."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_constrains)

    def test_removed_constraints(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed constraints."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_constrains)

    def test_added_validatetrans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added validatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_validatetrans)

    def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed validatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)

    def test_added_mlsconstraints(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added mlsconstraints."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)

    def test_removed_mlsconstraints(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all mlsconstraints removed."""
        self.assertEqual(
            sum(1 for m in self.diff.left_policy.constraints() if m.ruletype == CRT.mlsconstrain),
            len(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains))

    def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added mlsvalidatetrans."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)

    def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: all mlsvalidatetrans removed."""
        self.assertEqual(
            sum(1 for m in self.diff.left_policy.constraints()
                if m.ruletype == CRT.mlsvalidatetrans),
            len(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans))

    def test_added_typebounds(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no added typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_typebounds)

    def test_removed_typebounds(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_typebounds)

    def test_modified_typebounds(self):
        """MLSvsStandardDiff: no modified typebounds."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_typebounds)

    def test_added_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_allowxperms)

    def test_removed_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_allowxperms)

    def test_modified_allowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified allowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_allowxperms)

    def test_added_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_auditallowxperms)

    def test_removed_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_auditallowxperms)

    def test_modified_auditallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified auditallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_auditallowxperms)

    def test_added_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_neverallowxperms)

    def test_removed_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_neverallowxperms)

    def test_modified_neverallowxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified neverallowxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_neverallowxperms)

    def test_added_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no added dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_dontauditxperms)

    def test_removed_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_dontauditxperms)

    def test_modified_dontauditxperms(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified dontauditxperm rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_dontauditxperms)

    def test_added_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_ibpkeycons)

    def test_removed_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_ibpkeycons)

    def test_modified_ibpkeycons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified ibpkeycon rules."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.ibpkeycon_count,
                         len(self.diff.modified_ibpkeycons))

    def test_added_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no added ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_ibendportcons)

    def test_removed_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no removed ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_ibendportcons)

    def test_modified_ibendportcons(self):
        """NoDiff: no modified ibendportcon rules."""
        self.assertEqual(self.diff.left_policy.ibendportcon_count,
                         len(self.diff.modified_ibendportcons))


class PolicyDifferenceTestRedundant(unittest.TestCase):

    """
    Policy difference test with redundant rules.
    There should be no policy differences.
    """

    @classmethod
    def setUpClass(cls):
        cls.p_left = compile_policy("tests/diff_left.conf")
        cls.p_right = compile_policy("tests/diff_left_redundant.conf")
        cls.diff = PolicyDifference(cls.p_left, cls.p_right)

    @classmethod
    def tearDownClass(cls):
        os.unlink(cls.p_left.path)
        os.unlink(cls.p_right.path)

    def test_added_allows(self):
        """Redundant: no added allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_allows)

    def test_removed_allows(self):
        """Redundant: no removed allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_allows)

    def test_modified_allows(self):
        """Redundant: no modified allow rules."""
        self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_allows)